Alright. First of all, let me say that I am SO glad that I didn't buy into the hype, and actually tried the game before buying it. Oh, and I tried out the PC version.
The graphics are good, if a bit inefficient and with a bit too many "cool" effects.
The interiors are VERY well done!
The sound is decent enough, but not too accurate.
The physics are better than a few previous games, although it still feels like you're piloting hovercrafts, not driving cars.
Now... I haven't tried this on a console with a gamepad, but on my PC with my G25.
The controls are totally friggin' horrible. The driving feel is AWFUL, and no matter how much I played with the settings, I get imprecise, sluggish and DELAYED steering response. The FFB feels like it is 10 years old, and really is more annoying than informative. It destroys the whole game for me...
I was not expecting much. I knew that it would be nowhere near stuff like LFS, rFactor and even the GTR-series, but the feel and response is worse than most of the newer NFS-titles!
To sum it up, it feels like someone else is actually driving the car under my instructions. I don't feel that I'm the one in control at all. Bah...