October Exercise 1 RESULTS

[Raheel]

There was a good turnup of entries but not enough voters....but still a result has come up .

Heres the Original Image of the poor car :

Original


And these were the entries for this exercise with their corresponding editors :

Chop 1 [blaydexi - FG]


Chop 2 [ATsucks - FG]


Chop 3 [YF19pilot - FG]


Chop 4 [Mischief007 - FG]


Chop 5 [TrueSlideXL - DS]


Chop 6 [s3r4x - FG]


Chop 7 [raheel_qamar - FG]


Chop 8 [hansvonaxion - FG]


Chop 9 [tranceshakeel - FG]


Chop 10 [A32 - DS]


Now for the results :

In 3rd position, with 8 points is blaydexi (FG)


In 2nd position, with 13 points is s3r4x (FG)


And the winner, with 20 points is once again ATsucks....


Congradulations to all the contestants and hope they will do better next time....

The Results Table : Download

[Raheel]

Originally Posted by ATsucks

First: 1

I like how the rims and front fender were changed, very well integrated with the car, and I like the subtle detail of the amber reflector. Although I would dial down the head and fog lights, a little too bright and blurry. The CF hood is very well done, but the under car neon lighting looks bad. It looks more like a red shadow than neon tubes lighting the floor.

Overall a very well done and clean design, it's subtle yet come across very strong.

Second: 6

I couldnt decide between my first and second choices, but although I'm not keen on the color choice, I think the front fender was well done.The left headlight shadow on the front fender isn't replicated on the right which gives away some of the illusion. The rear rim looks a little flat, but I like the detail of the front tire showing through the side vent, although the tire highlight shoud have been white rather than purple.

Third: 5

Maybe its because I like this car in white, but although not much was done to this car, I like the overal idea. The Mercedes big rims, though I don't like and the rear looks flat and thin, really add to the theme that I think the designer was going for. The red Holden emblem is a nice touch... it looks very Honda R-type ish, along with the fake xenon headlights.

Originally Posted by Mischief007

1st Position: Chop 6: Clean lines. Nice two-tone job.
2nd Position: Chop 1: Clean, nice paint job. Cleanly done.
3rd Position: Chop 3: Great hatchback conversion.

Originally Posted by tranceshakeel

Chop 2 - because it looks Perfect, nice vents, vinyl looks cool and the back view looks very nice too, an overall perfect chop.

Chop 6 - Bumper looks cool with the car, the colour is cool, nice job on the sides.

Chop 5 - Third position was really a chop 1 and chop5 but overall chop 5 pulled my attention more because it gives an executive look to the already brutal Monaro, sort of like gangsta rapper in a white suit !

Originally Posted by hansvonaxion

votes as follows:

1st: chop 2
2nd: chop 6
3rd: chop 5

chop 2: great work on the paintjob. lots of effort.

chop 6: good blending of bodykit. not so sure about the 2-tone paint, but good effort.

chop 5: close call with chop3. intersting choice of rims, work quite well.

Originally Posted by s3r4x

1st place = chop 2 (atsucks's ... it must be)
2nd place = chop 5 (was my favorite on style but the chop 2 was so much better technically so i had to put it first)
3rd place = chop 10

Originally Posted by A32 - DS

1st: chop 2
You can tell that a lot of time was put into it. They even went to the trouble of make a matching rear view. There are lots of little details like the V8 badge on the grill. The only bad thing i have to say about this chop is the defusers on the front bumper. They don't look real at all.

2nd: chop 3
The extended rear window give the car a totally new look to it. Overall it is a very clean looking chop. They could have done a little more work to it... at least some wheels.

3rd: chop 1
I like the new front bumper on it. I liked the fact that you actually used different wheel for the front and the back. I really don't like it when you can tell that they are the same wheel. The lense flares were a bad idea. They make chops look very "noob". I'd use the blur tool around the under car neons.

Originally Posted by I

1st = Chop 6
Some professionalism seen, I liked the styling of the color...

2nd = Chop 2
Same as chop 2 but liked chop 6 more...A lot of hard work and accuracy seen.

3rd = Chop 9
My Guess was that there was some brushing involved. the bumper would have looked better with a grill though.

[tranceshakeel]

Congratulations to ATsucks, a cool lookin monaro, that is !

[ATsucks]

Thanks for the votes and the comments everyone.
I got a PM from tranceshakeel to post a post a new image for the next exercise so here it is:

Click here to check it out!

Enjoy the image!

[Renesis]

shit, some of you guys are becoming quite good!

[s3r4x]

Thank you for the comments.. and i got some critic also which is good . I also noticed that rear rim but i couldnt do anything for it.

[Raheel]

congrats to the winner..and all others...I am back to my losing streak..

[ATsucks]

give yourself more credit dude, your chop is fine, just need to keep trying till you find a style and method that works and agrees with you