See my previous post about the sti, rx-8, 350Z, the S2000 falls in there too. I agree they're all great cars though and I do recommend them to my friends.
I'm not looking for a roadster/convertible. I honestly would never put the top down, that's just me.
I'm not looking for a car to show off, I'm looking for a car to DRIVE, and when I say drive I mean really drive for fun on back roads and taking to the track, power slides and just enjoying the entire driving experience.
To answer the question of insurance: I live in northern VA and I've checked, it'll cost around $200/month for full coverage. I feel sorry for anyone living in NJ.
As for Jags... Even though I think they're great, I just... I can't get over the interior, I'm sorry. It just looks like an old mans car. Also, I'd like to drive a manual.
Alot of you are saying RS4 and Vette, so I'm going to test drive those next week and let you know.
I agree with a lot of you that the cayman s looks great. IMO it's the best looking porsche out there. If I come across a good deal for a 1 year old used one, I just may go for that. But that also goes for the M coupe if it's blue w/ carbon leather trim, mmm sexy.
Thanks for everyone's input!