I know I'm going to get shit for it but I've always liked the Jeep Patriot, and after doing my usual random ebay browsing, I also have a soft spot for the Dodge Caliber as well. Before, the interior was so horrible that it would have been my sole reason for vetoing it if I were in the market for a new car:
So many things wrong...the way the vents were aimed at your crotch instead of at your face, the hard plastic everywhere, just a mess...
but now, at least in photos, it looks great.
I'd drive one.
I also have a soft spot for the 97-2001 Toyota Camry.
/hands in "car enthusiast" card