To be honest I don't know why it has been decided that Richard needs to be portrayed as stupidly stupid and I agree that it makes the cocking about even more painful to watch. A few years ago he did say, rather petulantly for him, when asked in an interview about his 'stupid little one' character and Andy stating that they had become cartoon versions of themselves - 'well he's the one that edits us that way' - so I don't really believe its ego-gratification on Richard's part and why would it be? It doesn't exactly do him any favours on or outside TG IMO.
I wasn't talking about Richard's ego being the one that's gratified by Stupid Richard's presence. Whose ego it is, I don't know, and I'm not going to speculate.
Perhaps we all try and rationalise these segments too much - and we should just lean back and let them flow over us.
I don't think we should. I tune in to the show to be entertained, not to have my intelligence insulted. I don't take well at all to having my intelligence insulted. I grew up an intellectual in a blue-collar environment, and it's a particular sore point with me. To this day, I don't suffer fools at all.
Andy and Jez obviously feel there is a place for this type of cocking about in TG and that they are enjoyed by a big enough proportion of the viewers otherwise they wouldn't do it. As much as these bits can make me wince I guess I respect Andy and Jez enough to trust that they know what they are doing.
""No one in this world, so far as I know-and I have searched the record for years, and employed agents to help me-has ever lost money by underestimating the intelligence of the great masses of the plain people." - H. L. Mencken
ETA: We're not the only ones who seem to feel that Stupid Richard's worn out his welcome. Did anyone else catch the exchange about Hammond on QI this week? I don't know if was on the standard version, but it made XL:
Jack Whitehall: "I felt sorry for an elephant the other day. I was watching this new BBC show, Planet Earth Live..."
Stephen Fry: "Oh, don't talk to me about that..."
Jack Whitehall: "Richard Hammond's on it. Richard Hammond was standing in front of these elephants in one of his tragic midlife-crisis necklaces, and it definitely had ivory on it."
After a Whitehall joke about an elephant beating up Hammond for doing that...
Alan Davies: "They put Richard Hammond out in the middle of the night with lots of lions around, just hoping that he would be savaged live on television."
Much later...
Stephen Fry: "What kind of ungulates do we find in the savannah?"
Jack Whitehall: "Richard Hammond." (accompanied by a slightly disgusted, strange look)
When QI goes after you, you're fucked.