The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) set off a firestorm last month with
a six-word tweet. “We are not endorsing Joe Biden,” it declared, reaffirming a public commitment made at last year’s DSA convention that Bernie Sanders was the only Democrat the group would endorse. Outraged pundits condemned the tweet as privileged; “from red to orange,” intoned one centrist wit. Leaders of the 1960s New Left wrote an open letter urging reconsideration.
As current and former co-chairs of the North Jersey chapter of DSA, we’d like to offer a leftist perspective on a controversy dominated by voices outside the contemporary left. The DSA is a democratic socialist organization that is fighting to create a society that works democratically for the people rather than the 1%. In North New Jersey, this has meant campaigning for Medicare for All, fighting to end our state’s massive ICE detention facilities, creating mutual aid networks and running our own candidates in local elections.
Most recently, our chapter engaged in a DSA for Bernie campaign in order to not just canvass for Bernie but to talk to thousands of people about democratic socialism and invite them into our movement to transform our society. This was a national campaign carried out by DSA chapters across the country who saw Bernie’s campaign as an explicitly class-struggle movement that understood that in order for working people to thrive in the U.S., our leaders need to confront the pharmaceutical industries, Wall Street, the fossil fuel industry, and companies such as Walmart and Amazon that constitute the ruling class of this country.
Meanwhile, here is how Joe Biden looks to those on the left: reactionary. His career has been defined by racism, extending from 1970s desegregation busing debates to mass incarceration; sexism and misogyny, from his support for the abortion restrictions of the Hyde Amendment to his silencing of Anita Hill, to the current allegations of sexual assault he faces; advocacy for insurance firms and the financial sector over the interests of working people; and avid support for the invasion of Iraq, the single greatest U.S. crime of the 21st century.
That’s a tough sell to any leftist wary of a return to the “normalcy” of the Obama years, which we remember as times of endless drone strikes and war, bailouts for banks, and more deportations than Trump has yet undertaken.
Yet this is the rhetoric we constantly hear: you must support Biden, or you’re responsible for Trump’s re-election! Think of the Supreme Court! (Despite, of course, the fact that Biden voted for Justice Scalia, helped assure Justice Thomas, and sat passively while Republicans stole Merrick Garland’s rightful seat.)
These arguments do not move many on the left, no matter how much you think they should. Good politics meets people where they are, not where you want them to be. DSA is a socialist organization, and as such, it will not and need not formally endorse Joe Biden, whose campaign merchandise proudly features “socialist” crossed off alongside “plutocrat,” as if they are equivalent. But defeating Trump and, more importantly, Trumpism are strategic DSA priorities, and to that end, we urge everyone to make more compelling arguments here by addressing left concerns.
Instead of vote-shaming the left, which might feel good but demonstrably does not work, those concerned about a Biden win might show that they are pushing Biden in more progressive directions. The COVID-19 pandemic is not just a medical crisis but a political one, ravaging communities already suffering from inequality. It shows clearly the need for much of the Sanders platform.
We believe swing state leftists should vote Biden, not because he deserves it but because a Democratic administration offers more fertile ground for the left than a Republican one, where we desperately scramble to fight for basic union, reproductive, immigrant, and queer/trans rights. For those seeking to build third-party power, we’ll do better under a Democrat as well, since Trump generates a false sense of “resistance” unity that obscures the deep divisions within the Dems.
But ultimately it’s Joe Biden’s job to win votes, not voters’ job to elect him. He won’t win without a coalition that includes significant support from Bernie Sanders voters. We don’t trust his promises or his platform, but serious overtures to the left such as commitments to cabinet positions for Sanders and brilliant flight-attendant union leader Sara Nelson would be a great start. Let’s defeat Trump and also the neoliberalism that spawned him!
Full article