October Exercise 1 RESULTS

[Raheel]

There was a good turnup of entries but not enough voters....but still a result has come up :lol: .

Heres the Original Image of the poor car :

Original
http://img369.imageshack.**/img369/4107/original3dy.jpg

And these were the entries for this exercise with their corresponding editors :

Chop 1 [blaydexi - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/6302/chop13gh.jpg

Chop 2 [ATsucks - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/3347/chop23ag.jpg

Chop 3 [YF19pilot - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/7541/chop33nz.jpg

Chop 4 [Mischief007 - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/1712/chop41rc.jpg

Chop 5 [TrueSlideXL - DS]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/3043/chop51mo.jpg

Chop 6 [s3r4x - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/781/chop64nw.jpg

Chop 7 [raheel_qamar - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/5867/chop79jb.jpg

Chop 8 [hansvonaxion - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/1686/chop82pr.jpg

Chop 9 [tranceshakeel - FG]
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/6320/chop91yd.jpg

Chop 10 [A32 - DS]
http://img401.imageshack.**/img401/3482/chop106ex.jpg

Now for the results :

In 3rd position, with 8 points is blaydexi (FG)
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/6302/chop13gh.jpg

In 2nd position, with 13 points is s3r4x (FG)
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/781/chop64nw.jpg

And the winner, with 20 points is once again ATsucks....
http://img431.imageshack.**/img431/3347/chop23ag.jpg

Congradulations to all the contestants and hope they will do better next time....

The Results Table : Download

 

[Raheel]

First: 1

I like how the rims and front fender were changed, very well integrated with the car, and I like the subtle detail of the amber reflector. Although I would dial down the head and fog lights, a little too bright and blurry. The CF hood is very well done, but the under car neon lighting looks bad. It looks more like a red shadow than neon tubes lighting the floor.

Overall a very well done and clean design, it's subtle yet come across very strong.

Second: 6

I couldnt decide between my first and second choices, but although I'm not keen on the color choice, I think the front fender was well done.The left headlight shadow on the front fender isn't replicated on the right which gives away some of the illusion. The rear rim looks a little flat, but I like the detail of the front tire showing through the side vent, although the tire highlight shoud have been white rather than purple.

Third: 5

Maybe its because I like this car in white, but although not much was done to this car, I like the overal idea. The Mercedes big rims, though I don't like and the rear looks flat and thin, really add to the theme that I think the designer was going for. The red Holden emblem is a nice touch... it looks very Honda R-type ish, along with the fake xenon headlights.

1st Position: Chop 6: Clean lines. Nice two-tone job.
2nd Position: Chop 1: Clean, nice paint job. Cleanly done.
3rd Position: Chop 3: Great hatchback conversion.

Chop 2 - because it looks Perfect, nice vents, vinyl looks cool and the back view looks very nice too, an overall perfect chop.

Chop 6 - Bumper looks cool with the car, the colour is cool, nice job on the sides.

Chop 5 - Third position was really a chop 1 and chop5 but overall chop 5 pulled my attention more because it gives an executive look to the already brutal Monaro, sort of like gangsta rapper in a white suit !

votes as follows:

1st: chop 2
2nd: chop 6
3rd: chop 5

chop 2: great work on the paintjob. lots of effort.

chop 6: good blending of bodykit. not so sure about the 2-tone paint, but good effort.

chop 5: close call with chop3. intersting choice of rims, work quite well.

1st place = chop 2 (atsucks's ... it must be)
2nd place = chop 5 (was my favorite on style but the chop 2 was so much better technically so i had to put it first)
3rd place = chop 10

1st: chop 2
You can tell that a lot of time was put into it. They even went to the trouble of make a matching rear view. There are lots of little details like the V8 badge on the grill. The only bad thing i have to say about this chop is the defusers on the front bumper. They don't look real at all.

2nd: chop 3
The extended rear window give the car a totally new look to it. Overall it is a very clean looking chop. They could have done a little more work to it... at least some wheels.

3rd: chop 1
I like the new front bumper on it. I liked the fact that you actually used different wheel for the front and the back. I really don't like it when you can tell that they are the same wheel. The lense flares were a bad idea. They make chops look very "noob". I'd use the blur tool around the under car neons.

1st = Chop 6
Some professionalism seen, I liked the styling of the color...

2nd = Chop 2
Same as chop 2 but liked chop 6 more...A lot of hard work and accuracy seen.

3rd = Chop 9
My Guess was that there was some brushing involved. the bumper would have looked better with a grill though.

 

[tranceshakeel]

Congratulations to ATsucks, a cool lookin monaro, that is !

 

[ATsucks]

Thanks for the votes and the comments everyone.
I got a PM from tranceshakeel to post a post a new image for the next exercise so here it is:

Click here to check it out!

Enjoy the image!

 

[Renesis]

shit, some of you guys are becoming quite good!

 

[s3r4x]

Thank you for the comments.. and i got some critic also which is good . I also noticed that rear rim but i couldnt do anything for it.

 

[Raheel]

congrats to the winner..and all others...I am back to my losing streak.. :lol:

 

[ATsucks]

give yourself more credit dude, your chop is fine, just need to keep trying till you find a style and method that works and agrees with you