An electric guitar's amp has a preamp which is specifically designed to "color" the signal from an electric guitar. Have you ever tried to play a cdplayer/mp3 player through a guitar-input on an electric guitar amp? It sounds like ass.
An acoustic amp is very similar to a simple PA, in that it's a very clean signal. Really the only things it's doing to the signal is EQ.
Computer recordings can sound pretty lifeless unless you've got a really rockin' mic. However, you can use "acoustic" pedals that are made to make an electric a little bit more acoustic sounding...but when you use 'em with an acoustic, it helps a bit ad some "sparkle."
I see. Hm, sounds like I can do a bit of experimenting on this one with hooking up an acoustic to my computer. Will have to look for some good processing plug-ins for guitars and see what they can do.
When I took Audio Production in college, we always mic'ed the acoustics to get as pure of a sound as possible, then we did all the EQ on the mixer, and some post processing stuff as well on the computer.
A good home studio setup would be to get a nice studio quality condenser mic, run that through a mixer, and then go from the mixer into your computer.
Yeah, a condenser mic is always a better choice for acoustic instruments, but the thing is, it may not be an option for me right now. Even if I do get the money to buy one ... which after buying a good guitar might be hard ... my problem comes from my studio setup.
My studio mainframe is basically a desktop computer. It's a beast in terms of processing power, but all that power needs powerful fans to cool it down. Unfortunately that means that the hum from this thing can be quite loud, and in a room as small as mine with a very good mic, it's sure to pick it up.
That's why, with all this background noise, mic-ing can be a problem. When I move out of my parent's house (which will be after I graduate) I may just have an idea to build a soundproof room in my house, but until then, it looks as if recording by mic is out of the question. And honestly, there's no point in doing a half-ass job.
So I might have to experiment in recording it the electric-acoustic way until recording by mic becomes an option.
As for a mixer, don't need one, I can do EQ digitally, very easy and with very good precision.
Thanks again, guys.