I think I can answer your question perfectly:
The Peugeot I've had for 3 years. My first car. Paid ?125 for it, done 35k miles, only needed service items, (oil, filters, plugs and tyres) a starter and a fuel pump (I may have killed the fuel pump though...). Fantastically reliable, very very cheap in everything (insurance, tax, petrol). A great laugh and fantastic to throw around. Been great this last winter as I've moved somewhere with crappy (slippery) roads so I was thankful for the front wheel drive. Plus if I crash it it's not a huge loss. Or if it rusts away from underneath thanks to our salty roads. I love it, but I think that she's going to fail her MOT later this month and there's a chance I won't bother repairing her.
The other one is my pride and joy. Had the MR2 for just under a year now. Love it to bits. I'm a post-grad student now, so can't thrash it if only down to petrol costs, but I love it too much to treat it too hard anyway... Done a mild restoration to it, (not quite finished yet) and managed to keep it in my parents garage during the Winter months just gone, but don't have that facility anymore.
The MR2 is a 1989 Mk1, and has 99874 miles on it - as of this evening...
It's definitely my weekend/Summer car - I tend to go to meets in it. Love the roof off capability. Just a fantastic car IMO. Definitely my weekend car, but recently it's been my daily driver too as the Pug has been unwell (fuel pump) - or jealous...
(Not that I mind too much - what a daily driver! I can have the crappiest day in the office but still have a HUGE smile after my 15 mile drive home on the A and B roads I have to take!!!!)
So, just to explain why I have two cars... down to the way the insurance is on these two (MR2 on classic car, limited mileage policy - with a lot less miles than I do a year; all the no-claims bonus on the Pug) the insurance & tax combined for two cars is cheaper than if I was running just the MR2. Weird, but true. This year that'll change though, and it'll probably just be MR2 all the way.
This photo was taken not after the MR2 had just been washed. Oh no, between the washing and this photo was a 200 mile round trip and a bit of time on a race circuit to attempt to set a world record... (most number of one model of car in a rolling convoy - we managed 293 MR2s).
Oh, and the oil spots on the floor are not mine.
So... that's my story...